Best Pancake Griddle 2017 – Reviews & Buyer’s Guide
Pancakes can be cooked in a lot of ways, but the griddle stands out as the best. It allows you to cook pancakes without additional oil and you can do a larger batch than skillets. The best pancake griddle should be durable, versatile, and easy to clean.
I got interested with pancake griddles when my friend suggested them over skillets in making pancakes. I was overwhelmed with the many brands and models of this kitchen equipment on the market, so I round up five of the most popular models for your convenience. If you’re curious to know what pancake griddle to buy, keep reading.
Why Use A Pancake Griddle?
Before I tell you the reasons why you should use a pancake griddle, let me describe what it is. A griddle is a flat cooking surface. While most surfaces are made of nonstick coating, there are some models that are made of cast iron.
We should use a pancake griddle because it offers a larger surface area than most skillets. By its large cooking surface, you can cook many pancakes at once. Flipping the pancakes will be easier with its flat surface.
A pancake griddle is versatile as it can also cook other food such as eggs, bacon, and meat. Cleaning can also be a breeze with its nonstick surface. Some models have removable parts to make them fully immersible.
A note from Paula: Do you want to learn how to make pancake without eggs? Are you preparing for breakfast by making a batch of pancakes but found no egg in your kitchen? No problem, click on the link above to learn more.
To make your pancakes' taste much more delicious, I recommend you to use a fine sifter. It will make your batter end up smooth. Find out more about my article on how to choose the best flour sifter.
Stovetop Griddle Vs Electric Griddle
In buying for the right pancake griddle for you, it’s imperative that you decide what to choose between a stovetop and an electric griddle. If you like a more durable griddle, choose a stovetop griddle because most of its models are made of cast iron and hard anodized aluminum. Watch how to make pancakes on a stovetop griddle in this video here.
For more convenience, an electric griddle is preferable because you can place it directly on the table and you can control the temperature as its desired setting. To use an electric griddle, preheat it first to 350 degrees Fahrenheit, then pour a small circle of batter on the surface. To flip the pancakes easily, set them 1 1/2 inches apart. You can watch how to make pancakes in an electric griddle in this video here.
Tips In Using A Pancake Griddle
In making pancakes, make sure that you preheat the griddle with a bit of cooking oil. You can tell if the surface is already hot for cooking if a drop of water evaporates once you pour it gently. If you like to be experimental, you can mix flavors by cooking two different foods simultaneously.
To keep the food from sticking to your griddle, add some cooking spray or a generous amount of oil. If you avoid greasy foods, lessen the oil by blotting the surface with paper towels. You can also wrap meat in foil to cook it thoroughly.
What To Look For
Aside from pancakes, it might be best if your pan can also cook other food, such as bacon, eggs, and steaks. If you want versatility, don’t settle for pancake griddle alone, but try to look for a grill combo with dual plates. By having a versatile pan, you can get your money’s worth.
2. Cool Handles
To look for a good pancake griddle, take special notice on the handles. Some brands may design a handle that will give you burns while it’s cooking. To make sure that you get your hands protected from potential burns, look for a handle that promises a “cool touch” feature.
Since you’ll be investing money in a good brand of pan griddle, make sure that the product offers a nice warranty. The warranty should cover all repairs and replacements in case of a defective unit. A longer warranty period is very much preferred so you can use your unit for many years to come.
4. Easy To Clean
For convenience, look for a pancake griddle that is easy to clean. Some units have parts that can be removed for easy cleaning, like a detachable drip tray. While other models are dishwasher-safe, some are suited for hand washing only
5. Durable Construction
The durability of a pancake may depend on the type of material used. Some durable materials that you should look for include hard anodized aluminum and cast iron. The handle should be riveted and the nonstick coating not easy to scratch.
Our Top 5 Picks
*Below, you'll find our more detailed reviews, but you can also click the links above to see current prices or read customer reviews on Amazon.
The Calphalon Contemporary Griddle is made of heavy-gauge aluminum for even heating capacity. To make it more durable, it is treated with an electro-chemical process to make hard anodized. Three layers of nonstick coating are made to provide a great nonstick performance.
Its stainless steel handles are made to remain cool on the stovetop. You can use this unit for oven-baking up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. Any repairs and replacements can be covered by its full lifetime warranty.
Editor's Rating: 98/100
Price on Amazon: $39.99
- Durable hard anodized aluminum construction
- Stay-cool handles for comfort
- PFOA-free nonstick coating surface
- Oven and dishwasher safe
- Can make good pancakes
- May warp easily due to heat
- The nonstick coating seems to wear off after a couple of months
- A bit pricey for its size
The Lodge L9OG3 is a round cast-iron griddle that offers excellent heat retention and dissemination. It already comes pre-seasoned so you can use this pan immediately. For convenient storage, this unit is designed with a hole on its durable handle.
To clean, just rinse with hot water and dry fully. With vegetable oil, you can season this unit after every use to keep its nonstick surface. This unit also offers a generous limited lifetime warranty to cover defects and replacements.
Editor's Rating: 95/100
Price on Amazon: $13.39
- Very affordable
- Multi-functional as it can also grill sandwiches, roast vegetables, and cook quesadillas
- Durable cast iron construction
- Long limited lifetime warranty
- Easy to clean and store
- Quite heavy
- Needs constant re-seasoning with vegetable oil to keep its non-stick surface
- May rust over time if not properly seasoned
- The handle may get too hot when in use
The Presto 07061 features an easy to clean drip tray to catch all excess oil from meat. Its premium nonstick surface offers a stick-free cooking and simple cleaning. Master heat control keeps the desired cooking temperature automatically.
Made from a heavy cast aluminum base, this griddle is technically warp-proof. If you remove the heat control. You can fully immerse this unit for easy cleaning. With handles detached, you store the base easily in standard kitchen cabinets.
Editor's Rating: 89/100
Price on Amazon: $34.90
- Great premium nonstick surface
- The handles don’t get hot while cooking
- Easy to clean with removable drip tray and detachable handles
- Versatile cooking
- Cooking surface may not heat evenly
- Handle may break off easily
- The little grooves seem to make the pancake batter stick to the surface
The Ecolution Artistry Non-Stick Griddle is an eco-friendly non-stick griddle which is made from heavy-gauge aluminum.. Similar to all Ecolution products, this model is free from perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA). Instead of using PFOA, Ecolution uses a water-based non-toxic coating known as Hydrolon.
Built with a soft silicone handle, you can expect it to remain cool even while cooking. Consistent heating is also ensured thanks to its grooved rings. For proper care and maintenance, never pour hot water into griddle as oil can splatter or else you’ll warp the bottom.
Editor's Rating: 84/100
Price on Amazon: $23.85
- Healthier and safer Hydrolon nonstick coating
- Affordable, yet durable
- Soft and stay cool handles
- Versatile as it can cook not other than pancakes, but also bacon, cheese and more
- Eco-friendly materials
- Doesn’t spread heat evenly
- May warp after a few uses
- The handle is too hefty
The Black + Decker GD2011B is a large non-stick griddle which can accommodate about eight servings. For easy cleanup, a drip tray is added into the unit. A temperature control is designed to provide variable heating from warm to 400 degrees Fahrenheit.
The great thing about this unit is it turns off once the desired temperature is reached. You can expect a great heat retention with a cast iron cooking surface. Aside from pancakes, you can cook meat, eggs, and hamburgers.
Editor's Rating: 78/100
Price on Amazon: from $29.99
- Can reach up to 400 degrees Fahrenheit for flexible cooking
- Easy to clean
- Drip tray is great in catching excess oil from food
- Nice large capacity
- The surface heat seems to spread unevenly
- The temperature dial is a bit hard to operate
- The nonstick surface easily peels off
- Cooks pancakes unevenly, with burnt exterior and uncooked center
Based on the reviews above, the Calphalon Contemporary Griddle is the best pancake griddle because it met most of the qualities of a good unit. The Calphalon has a durable hard anodized aluminum construction, a full lifetime warranty, and a stay-cool handle. It’s easy to clean and PFOA-free.
If you own a pancake griddle, tell us your thoughts in the comments section below. Don’t forget to share this wonderful article with your friends and family if you find this helpful.