How to Soften Marshmallows: Easy Tips and Tricks

You know why people love marshmallows so much? It is because of the sheer delight of biting into a perfectly soft and fluffy marshmallow. One bite and a sweet goodness melts in your mouth like a cloud of sugary bliss.

Everyone loves a marshmallow. However, every marshmallow fan knows these delightful confections can sometimes turn very hard or lose their signature soft texture over time. We can help you learn how to soften marshmallows.

Imagine that you have ever felt disappointed by a bag of rock-hard marshmallows or stumbled upon a stale stash tucked away in your pantry. What would you do?

Well we are here to save your marshmallow dreams and unveil the secrets to softening them like a pro.

Whether you are craving to toast them for slushy s’mores by the campfire, add a luscious touch to your hot cocoa, or add the magic into your favorite baking recipes.

Our expert tips and tricks will have your marshmallows soft, fluffy, and ready to elevate your culinary concepts to new heights.

7 Methods to Soften Marshmallows

How to Soften Marshmallows

Softening marshmallows is an art, and we have some fantastic methods to share with you that will leave your marshmallows fluffy and delightful once again.

Let us dive into the details of each method and learn how to make marshmallows soft like a pro!

Method 1: Naturally

Leaving marshmallows at room temperature for a few hours is the quickest and simplest technique to soft them.

As a result, the marshmallows will become more malleable and simpler to chew, thanks to the gelatin and corn syrup softening process.

For this, keep the marshmallows in an airtight container at room temperature.

Method 2: Hot Water

If your marshmallows have lost their softness and turned into tiny marshmallow boulders, we have a simple solution.

If you are in a rush for a soft marshmallow fix, the Hot Water Method is your go-to option. 

Follow the steps below for this method:

  • Get yourself a sealable plastic bag and place the hardened marshmallows inside.
  • You have to seal the bag tightly.
  • Next, take a bowl of hot water and immerse the bag.
  • Let it sit for about a minute.

The combination of moisture inside the bag and the heat from the water will work their magic, resulting in soft, squishy marshmallows.

Just ensure no holes are in the bag, as water seepage can melt the marshmallows within seconds.

Method 3: Bread Slices

The Bread Slices Method, a time-tested technique, requires a bit of patience but yields excellent results. 

To use this method, follow the steps below:

  • Take a sealable plastic bag.
  • Add a couple of bread slices to it.
  • Now, place the marshmallows into the bag.
  • Seal it tightly, and let it rest for one or two days.

The bread slices release moisture over time, creating a foggy environment inside the bag that gently softens the marshmallows.

While it might not be suitable for quick fixes, this method is perfect for reviving marshmallows over a longer duration.

Method 4: Microwave Method

When it comes to speed, the Microwave Method takes the crown.

It only takes a few seconds to make marshmallows soft using this technique, but beware—overheating can lead to charred marshmallows.

To avoid this, follow the steps below:

  • Place a cup of water alongside the marshmallow bowl in the microwave.
  • Heat it for around ten seconds.

The moisture from the cup and the microwave’s heat will work together to make marshmallows soft in no time.

Method 5: Use Sugar

How to Soften Marshmallows

If you have slightly stale marshmallows, the Sugar Method is your savior.

Stale marshmallows tend to stick together when heated, making hot water or microwave methods ineffective.

To solve this:

  • Place the stale marshmallows in a plastic bag with powdered sugar.
  • Give it a good shake.
  • You will notice the marshmallows separating easily.

Keep in mind that this method is specifically for tackling stale marshmallows.

Method 6: Steam Bath

For those who prefer a gentler approach, a steam bath is the way to go.

The gentle steam will gradually make the marshmallows soft without any risk of overheating.

  • Grab a heat-resistant bowl.
  • Put your marshmallows inside.
  • Place the bowl over a pot of simmering water.
  • Now, cover the bowl with a lid and let the steam work its magic.

Method 7: Pan-frying or Grilling Marshmallows

Grill or pan-frying the marshmallows after cutting them into tiny slices.

This will aid in giving the marshmallows’ outside a wonderful, toasted crispness that will make them simpler to chew.

To achieve this:

  • Cut the marshmallows into slices that are 1/4-inch-thick.
  • Then add the slices to a hot, dry skillet.
  • The marshmallows should be cooked for 1-2 minutes over medium heat or until the outsides are crisp and lightly browned.

Which Marshmallows Are Softer: Fresh or Stale?

How to Soften Marshmallows

Fresh marshmallows tend to be softer and more delightful straight out of the bag. However, don’t worry if you have some stale marshmallows lying around.

With the right techniques, you can easily restore them to their previous form and enjoy their softness just like the fresh ones.

Fresh marshmallows are generally softer and more enjoyable straight out of the bag.

They have a fluffy and squishy texture, making them perfect for snacking and s’mores.

Stale marshmallows can become hard over time. However, they can be softened with a slice of bread in a resealable bag or steam bath.

Reviving stale marshmallows may not fully restore their original softness.

However, they can still be used in hot cocoa, baking, or melted in various recipes.

For snacking and s’mores, fresh marshmallows are the best choice. Fresh and softened marshmallows can be used effectively for baking or melting.

Storing Marshmallows for Longevity

To keep your marshmallows fluffy and delightful for a longer time, proper storage is essential.

Follow these tips to ensure your marshmallows stay in tip-top shape:

  • Airtight Containers: Transfer your marshmallows to an airtight container. This simple step will protect them from exposure to air and moisture, both of which can cause them to harden.
  • Avoid Humidity: Find a cool, dry spot away from direct sunlight and humidity to store your marshmallows. Excess moisture can lead to clumping and spoilage, so keeping them dry is crucial.
  • Desiccant Packets: You should add desiccant packets to the container with your marshmallows. These little helpers absorb any excess moisture and help maintain the ideal fluffy texture.


How to Soften Marshmallows

So, there you have it—a comprehensive guide on various marshmallow softening methods!

Select the one method that suits your needs, and soon you will be enjoying the softest, most delightful marshmallows you have ever experienced.

Softening marshmallows is an art worth mastering.

With these techniques and storage practices, you can fully enjoy these fluffy treats and take your culinary creations to a whole new level of delight. 

Whether you are roasting marshmallows around a campfire or adding them to your favorite recipes, their soft, sweet goodness is sure to bring joy to every bite.

So, go ahead, and let your imagination run wild in the kitchen!

Happy marshmallow adventures!

With these techniques at your use, there is no more disappointment when it comes to enjoying your favorite fluffy treats.

Get ready to savor the sweet secrets to fluffy bliss!


Q1: Can I use the oven to make marshmallows soft?

Ans: You can use the oven to make marshmallows soft. However, it is not recommended. It can quickly lead to overcooking and result in melted, gooey marshmallows.

The high and direct heat of the oven is not suitable for this delicate sweet.  You can use the methods mentioned above, like the microwave or steam bath, for better results.

Q2: Can I soften marshmallows using a damp cloth or paper towel? 

Ans: While it might seem like a quick solution, using a damp cloth or paper towel to make marshmallows soft is not recommended.

The dampness from the cloth or towel might cause the marshmallows to become soggy and you might lose their fluffy texture.

Q3: Can I freeze marshmallows to keep them soft? 

Ans: Freezing marshmallows can help maintain their freshness. It prevents them from going stale.

However, freezing won’t necessarily help if they have already become hard.

To soften frozen marshmallows, you have to thaw them at room temperature or use one of the softening methods mentioned earlier.

Q4: How do I know if marshmallows are too stale to be softened? 

Ans: Marshmallows that have become too hard and dry might not be edible.

You can make them better by using the softening methods mentioned above.

If the marshmallows are rock-solid and have lost their original shape and texture, it might be best to replace them with a fresh batch.

Q5: Can I make marshmallows soft without using any additional ingredients or methods? 

Ans: If you have some time on your hands, you can leave marshmallows out at room temperature in a dry and cool environment for a day or two.

This natural approach will allow the marshmallows to absorb moisture from the air and regain some of their softness.

Q6: How can I store marshmallows to prevent them from hardening? 

Ans: You should store marshmallows at room temperature in a sealed container.

This will keep them soft and fluffy for a longer time.

Make sure the container doesn’t get wet or get too much sun because these things can make the marshmallows harden over time.

Q7: Can I add softened marshmallows to liquid-based recipes? 

Ans: Yes, softened marshmallows can be easily added into liquid-based recipes like hot cocoa, pudding, or smoothies.

Make sure that the marshmallows are completely softened before adding them to avoid lumps in your recipes.

Q8: Can I use a food processor to make marshmallows soft? 

Ans: Using a food processor to make marshmallows soft is not recommended.

The blades of the food processor can chop the marshmallows into tiny pieces instead of restoring their original fluffy texture.

Leave a Comment