Finding The Best Yogurt Maker: What You Need To Know When Buying

Are you deciding to buy a yogurt maker for your family? Then take the time to read this article as we guide you how to make the best worth of your money. The best yogurt maker should fit in your budget, safe, and efficient.

I began to search for a good yogurt maker after knowing the many benefits of making one at home, health-wise and money-wise. However, buying yogurt makers can be confusing with the many brands available on the market now. So for your convenience, we'll review five of the best yogurt makers and some helpful guidelines that you can follow.

**Below, you'll find our more detailed reviews, but you can also click the links above to see current prices or read customer reviews on Amazon.


What Is A Yogurt Maker?


A yogurt maker is a machine that can create yogurt in small serving-sized jars, or in a large single vat. You can invest in a basic yogurt maker in as low as $20, or you can spend as much as $500 with a lot of features.

Although yogurt makers can vary in features and size, they share a common function of keeping the yogurt at a steady temperature (110-115 degrees Fahrenheit) for about 6-8 hours.

Advantages Of Using A Yogurt Maker


Getting a yogurt maker is worth an investment because you can create some healthy snacks in the comfort of your home. Unlike commercial yogurts which contain sugar, artificial flavors, and preservatives, homemade yogurt is all natural.

You can save money in the long run because buying individual cups are more expensive than making your own. Using a yogurt maker also ensures great tasting yogurt in just simple steps: Fill the jars with ingredients you like, plug the machine, and wait overnight to ferment.

What To Look For


1. Capacity

The capacity of a yogurt maker can be determined by its size and number of jars. Yogurt makers with jars are typically known as tall cover models. Some tall cover models offer seven 7-ounce glass jars with a total capacity of 49 ounces.

If you like a larger capacity, look for single jars which can allow you to make yogurt in a single batch. However, you can't make multiple flavors like you can do with tall cover models.

2. Safety

Since we'll be heating ingredients to make yogurt, it is best that you look for glass jars and not their plastic counterparts. If you use plastic jars, some chemicals might leach into your yogurt when exposed to heat. Some plastic cups are marked as BPA-free, but this doesn't mean safe because it still has the same structure as BPA.

3. Price

For every purchase, it's always desirable to pay a reasonable price. You can find good yogurt makers below $100. If you're still a novice, it is advisable to choose a basic model which normally costs around $20-40. As you gain experience, you can choose a higher end model with more advanced features and a higher price.

4. Warranty

Any electric appliance may have defects after you purchase it or will stop working after a few months. To avoid wasting your money, look for a unit that is backed by a long warranty. Most models offer 1-3 years limited warranty. The longer, the better.

5. Convenient Features

Its convenient features can determine a yogurt maker's ease of use. Timer controls will make it convenient to set the heating time as recommended in a recipe. If you like to leave your unit overnight, then it will be desirable to have an automatic shut-off which turns off your unit after your yogurt is done.

An LCD feature makes it easier to see the time counting down until done. To keep track of the date, you can look for dateable lids. A dishwasher-safe feature is also helpful to look for so you can clean the unit very easily.

Our Top 5 Recommendations

1. Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker

The Euro Cuisine YM80 comes with seven 6-ounce glass containers which allow you to create seven different flavors in one setting. It features an on/off switch and light to indicate that the yogurt maker is working. A manual timer is designed to set the time for the fermentation process.

The whole process can take about 6-8 hours, so it's best to make your yogurt the night before. You don't have to worry about any defects within the few years because this product comes with 3-year warranty. If you value price above everything else, then the YM80 might be perfect for you.


  • Durable dishwasher safe glass jars
  • Very affordable given its 42-ounce capacity
  • Good 3-year warranty for guaranteed service
  • Creates wonderful yogurt


  • Would have been perfect if it has an auto shut-off feature and an auto timer
  • May kill some good bacteria because the unit seems to get too hot
  • Lids may warp if washed with hot water
  • The jars tend to get leaky sometimes because they're not water-tight

2. The Set And Go Electric Yogurt Maker by Epica Homemade Organic

The Epica Electric Yogurt Maker can create seven 6-ounce yogurts in various flavors. With dishwasher-safe glass jars and lids, you can create thick and sweet yogurt. A 3-year warranty comes with the product to cover any defects within your first three years of purchase.

This electric yogurt maker can create yogurt between 6-12 hours. Just add ingredients, set the timer, and walk away. If you're a beginner, then the Epica Yogurt Maker is a good start for you.


  • Good 3-year warranty for any defect coverage
  • Safe glass jars
  • Great price for a 42-ounce capacity
  • Makes a thicker yogurt if milk is heated first


  • Its high temperature ( 125-136 degrees) may produce watery yogurt with dead bacteria
  • The lids are not tightened well
  • Lacks some convenient features, like automatic shutoff and timer

3. Aroma Housewares AYM-606 8-Cup Digital Yogurt Maker

The Aroma Housewares AYM-606 is an electric yogurt maker with eight BPA-free plastic cups. The lids are leak-resistant so you can be assured of no water leaks and mess-free performance. Its convenient features is what I really love about this unit is, like automatic shut-off, digital display, and programmable timer.

This digital yogurt maker promises to make yogurt between 7-9 hours. A one-year limited warranty comes with this unit to make sure that any defects can be covered after purchase. If you're looking for a yogurt maker with great features at a low price, then the AYM-606 is the right one for you.


  • Easy to use
  • Nice features considering its affordable price
  • Sufficient one-year warranty
  • Intuitive control panel


  • Would have been better if the cups are made of glass
  • The cups are too small

4. Euro Cuisine YMX650 Automatic Digital Yogurt Maker

The Euro Cuisine YMX650 can create 42 ounces of yogurt with its seven 6-ounces glass jars. What I love about their glass jars are the dateable lids which allow you to mark the date of expiration. An LCD display shows the time of the fermentation process while a 15-hour countdown timer is built.

An automatic shut-off feature makes this unit more convenient to use. All YMX650 are backed with a 3-year warranty. If you like a digital yogurt maker with dateable glass jars, then the YM650 might suit your preference.


  • Easy to use thanks to its convenient features, like LCD display and programmable timer
  • Good automatic shutoff function for convenient use
  • Excellent glass jars with dateable lids
  • Generous 3-year warranty


  • The unit seems to get too hot
  • The bottom of the glass jars have grooves that are difficult to clean

5. Cuisinart CYM-100 Electronic Yogurt Maker

The Cuisinart CYM-100 can make yogurt up to 50 ounces or 1.5 liters. Time controls help you set the suggested fermenting time with great accuracy. The built-in cooling system is what I love about this unit. It automatically changes to the right chilling temperature.

Digital time display allows you see the time counting down. This unit also makes your kitchen look elegant with its stainless steel styling. If you want a large capacity single jar yogurt maker then the CYM-100 might be your solution.


  • Large capacity at 50 ounces or 1.5 liters
  • Easy to use with LED display, start/stop buttons, and time controls
  • Durable stainless steel construction
  • Great cooling system which shifts to the desired chilling temperature


  • Would have been perfect if the yogurt container is not made of plastic
  • A bit expensive
  • Replacement parts are hard to find


Based on the ratings above, the Euro Cuisine YMX650 is the best yogurt maker because it has most of the features desired. For instance, it has glass jars with dateable lids, LCD display, automatic shut-off, long warranty, and countdown timer. If you like to spend more, you can buy the Cuisinart CYM-100 because it has a very large capacity of 1.5 liters and an automatic cooling feature.

Have you tried using a yogurt maker? Let us know what your experiences are in the comments section below. If you find this article informative, you can share it on your social media accounts.

Paula Hughes

I’m Paula, and I’m absolutely in love with food blogs. I’m a foodie at heart but being the mother of two small boys, it’s not always easy to keep up with fancy dinners… so I rely on the support of other blogging moms like me to help along the way.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: